{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "@id": "https://sonsteng.damienriehl.com/platform/data/index.json", "title": "Sonsteng Practicum — machine catalog", "description": "Agent/LMS entry point for the practicum data spine. All paths are relative to this file. Instructor-side materials (master fact patterns, instructor notes, persona disclosure tiers) are intentionally absent.", "generated_by": "tools/build_site.py", "matters": [ { "id": "m01", "slug": "m01-arbitration-meridian", "caption": "Halden Regional Transit District v. Marceline Osgard and Meridian Alliance of Public Workers, Local 7 (Arbitration)", "shape": "employment_arbitration", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m01.role.employer-counsel", "label": "Employer / Halden Regional Transit District" }, { "role_id": "m01.role.employee-counsel", "label": "Grievant & Union / Marceline Osgard and MAPW Local 7" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m01.per.dellwood", "name": "Theo Dellwood", "role": "fact witness (coworker mechanic)", "interviewable_by": [ "m01.role.employee-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m01.per.osgard", "name": "Marceline Osgard", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m01.role.employee-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m01.per.rennick", "name": "Gerald Rennick", "role": "adverse party representative (maintenance superintendent)", "interviewable_by": [ "m01.role.employer-counsel" ], "represented": true } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m01-arbitration-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m01-arbitration-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m01-arbitration-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m01-arbitration-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m01.rub", "declared_total": 202, "criteria": [ { "id": "m01.rub.c01", "name": "Case theory and just-cause analysis", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-001" }, { "id": "m01.rub.c02", "name": "Fact investigation and chronology", "weight_points": 35, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m01.rub.c03", "name": "Client and witness interviewing", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m01.rub.c04", "name": "Written advocacy: statement of the case", "weight_points": 32, "skill_id": "SK-LP-09", "task_id": "TSK-005" }, { "id": "m01.rub.c05", "name": "Hearing advocacy: direct and cross", "weight_points": 35, "skill_id": "SK-LP-08", "task_id": "TSK-027" }, { "id": "m01.rub.c06", "name": "Professional responsibility and judgment", "weight_points": 15, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": null } ] } }, { "id": "m02", "slug": "m02-discipline-meridian", "caption": "In re Petition for Disciplinary Action against Gregor A. Winterhalt, a Meridian Attorney", "shape": "attorney_discipline", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m02.role.disciplinary-counsel", "label": "Petitioner / Disciplinary Counsel (Meridian Office of Lawyer Conduct)" }, { "role_id": "m02.role.respondent-counsel", "label": "Respondent / Gregor A. Winterhalt" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m02.per.fenwick", "name": "Nadia Fenwick", "role": "fact witness (former legal assistant)", "interviewable_by": [ "m02.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m02.per.marchetti", "name": "Delia Marchetti", "role": "complaining witness (former client)", "interviewable_by": [ "m02.role.disciplinary-counsel", "m02.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m02.per.winterhalt", "name": "Gregor A. Winterhalt", "role": "client (respondent attorney)", "interviewable_by": [ "m02.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m02-discipline-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m02-discipline-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m02-discipline-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m02-discipline-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m02.rub", "declared_total": 207, "criteria": [ { "id": "m02.rub.c01", "name": "Trust-accounting and safekeeping analysis", "weight_points": 55, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-061" }, { "id": "m02.rub.c02", "name": "Diligence and communication analysis", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" }, { "id": "m02.rub.c03", "name": "Sanction analysis and proportionality", "weight_points": 42, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-005" }, { "id": "m02.rub.c04", "name": "Client interview and counseling", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m02.rub.c05", "name": "Respondent's pre-hearing brief", "weight_points": 25, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-032" }, { "id": "m02.rub.c06", "name": "Oral argument and negotiation", "weight_points": 15, "skill_id": "SK-LP-08", "task_id": "TSK-026" } ] } }, { "id": "m03", "slug": "m03-tort-meridian", "caption": "Lorraine Petimeyer v. Douglas Ashcombe", "shape": "auto_negligence", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "contingency", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m03.role.plaintiff", "label": "Plaintiff / Lorraine Petimeyer" }, { "role_id": "m03.role.defense", "label": "Defendant / Douglas Ashcombe" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m03.per.ashcombe", "name": "Douglas Ashcombe", "role": "defendant driver", "interviewable_by": [ "m03.role.plaintiff", "m03.role.defense" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m03.per.petimeyer", "name": "Lorraine Petimeyer", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m03.role.plaintiff" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m03.per.quesada", "name": "Rafael Quesada", "role": "independent eyewitness", "interviewable_by": [ "m03.role.plaintiff", "m03.role.defense" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m03-tort-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m03-tort-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m03-tort-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m03-tort-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m03.rub", "declared_total": 325, "criteria": [ { "id": "m03.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview & fact development", "weight_points": 70, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m03.rub.c02", "name": "Case theory & liability analysis", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-001" }, { "id": "m03.rub.c03", "name": "Litigation execution", "weight_points": 90, "skill_id": "SK-LP-14", "task_id": "TSK-049" }, { "id": "m03.rub.c04", "name": "Damages & causation proof", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m03.rub.c05", "name": "Client counseling & settlement judgment", "weight_points": 35, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-034" }, { "id": "m03.rub.c06", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 25, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m04", "slug": "m04-realestate-meridian", "caption": "In re Purchase of 4400 Kestrel Point, Sable County (Renard–Meskin)", "shape": "real_estate_negotiation", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m04.role.buyer-counsel", "label": "Buyer's Counsel (Talbot Meskin)" }, { "role_id": "m04.role.seller-counsel", "label": "Seller's Counsel (Ruth Renard)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m04.per.delahaye", "name": "Corwin Delahaye", "role": "adjoining landowner (fact witness)", "interviewable_by": [ "m04.role.buyer-counsel", "m04.role.seller-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m04.per.meskin", "name": "Talbot Meskin", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m04.role.buyer-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m04.per.renard", "name": "Ruth Renard", "role": "seller / opposing party", "interviewable_by": [ "m04.role.seller-counsel", "m04.role.buyer-counsel" ], "represented": true } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m04-realestate-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m04-realestate-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m04-realestate-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m04-realestate-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m04.rub", "declared_total": 185.5, "criteria": [ { "id": "m04.rub.c01", "name": "Strategic negotiation plan (SSNP)", "weight_points": 50, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-044" }, { "id": "m04.rub.c02", "name": "Access-rights analysis (easement vs. license)", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m04.rub.c03", "name": "Purchase-agreement drafting", "weight_points": 40.5, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-062" }, { "id": "m04.rub.c04", "name": "Client counseling and fact-gathering", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-034" }, { "id": "m04.rub.c05", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 20, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m05", "slug": "m05-dwi-meridian", "caption": "State of Meridian v. Devon R. Halvard", "shape": "criminal_dwi", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "flat", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m05.role.defense", "label": "Defense / Defendant" }, { "role_id": "m05.role.prosecution", "label": "Prosecution / State of Meridian" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m05.per.broshears", "name": "Officer Curtis Broshears", "role": "arresting officer (State's witness)", "interviewable_by": [ "m05.role.prosecution" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m05.per.halvard", "name": "Devon R. Halvard", "role": "client (criminal defendant)", "interviewable_by": [ "m05.role.defense" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m05-dwi-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m05-dwi-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m05-dwi-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m05-dwi-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m05.rub", "declared_total": 316.5, "criteria": [ { "id": "m05.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview and fact development", "weight_points": 90, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m05.rub.c02", "name": "Issue-spotting: stop, field tests, and breath sample", "weight_points": 80, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-001" }, { "id": "m05.rub.c03", "name": "Counseling a distressed client", "weight_points": 56.5, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" }, { "id": "m05.rub.c04", "name": "Plea and charge negotiation strategy", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-045" }, { "id": "m05.rub.c05", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m06", "slug": "m06-noncompete-meridian", "caption": "Northlake Surgical Instruments, Inc. v. Adaeze Okwuosa", "shape": "noncompete_trade_secret", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m06.role.plaintiff", "label": "Plaintiff / Former Employer" }, { "role_id": "m06.role.defense", "label": "Defendant / Former Employee (our client)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m06.per.calderaro", "name": "Dr. Elena Calderaro", "role": "hospital purchasing director (non-party fact witness)", "interviewable_by": [ "m06.role.plaintiff", "m06.role.defense" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m06.per.danneker", "name": "Priscilla Danneker", "role": "director of sales, Northlake Surgical Instruments (adverse party representative)", "interviewable_by": [ "m06.role.plaintiff", "m06.role.defense" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m06.per.okwuosa", "name": "Adaeze Okwuosa", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m06.role.defense" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m06-noncompete-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m06-noncompete-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m06-noncompete-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m06-noncompete-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m06.rub", "declared_total": 189, "criteria": [ { "id": "m06.rub.c01", "name": "Temporary-injunction standard analysis", "weight_points": 70, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-011" }, { "id": "m06.rub.c02", "name": "Fact development and investigation", "weight_points": 35, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m06.rub.c03", "name": "Persuasive written advocacy", "weight_points": 44, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-032" }, { "id": "m06.rub.c04", "name": "Professional-responsibility and client-counseling judgment", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m07", "slug": "m07-ucc-meridian", "caption": "Cloverdyke Dairy Cooperative v. Brandt Refrigeration Systems, LLC", "shape": "ucc_sale_of_goods", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m07.role.buyer", "label": "Buyer / Claimant — Cloverdyke Dairy Cooperative" }, { "role_id": "m07.role.seller", "label": "Seller / Respondent — Brandt Refrigeration Systems, LLC" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m07.per.aaberg", "name": "Nils Aaberg", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m07.role.buyer" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m07.per.brandt", "name": "Sylvia Brandt", "role": "opposing party representative", "interviewable_by": [ "m07.role.seller" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m07.per.tuvang", "name": "Reuben Tuvang", "role": "fact witness", "interviewable_by": [ "m07.role.buyer" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m07-ucc-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m07-ucc-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m07-ucc-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m07-ucc-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m07.rub", "declared_total": 200, "criteria": [ { "id": "m07.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview and fact development", "weight_points": 50, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m07.rub.c02", "name": "Warranty and remedies analysis", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-010" }, { "id": "m07.rub.c03", "name": "Remedies, damages, and causation strategy", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-006" }, { "id": "m07.rub.c04", "name": "ADR strategy and client counseling", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-047" }, { "id": "m07.rub.c05", "name": "Professional responsibility and written communication", "weight_points": 20, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": null } ] } }, { "id": "m08", "slug": "m08-juvenile-meridian", "caption": "In re the Welfare of T.M., a Minor", "shape": "juvenile_delinquency", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m08.role.prosecution", "label": "Prosecution / State (Halden County Attorney)" }, { "role_id": "m08.role.defense", "label": "Juvenile Defense Counsel (Respondent)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m08.per.dubourg", "name": "Kellan Dubourg", "role": "co-respondent charged separately (represented party)", "interviewable_by": [ "m08.role.defense" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m08.per.merrow-d", "name": "Dana Merrow", "role": "parent / guardian of the client", "interviewable_by": [ "m08.role.defense" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m08.per.merrow-t", "name": "Tobias Merrow", "role": "client (juvenile respondent)", "interviewable_by": [ "m08.role.defense" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m08-juvenile-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m08-juvenile-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m08-juvenile-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m08-juvenile-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m08.rub", "declared_total": 220, "criteria": [ { "id": "m08.rub.c01", "name": "Fact investigation & the minor-client interview", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m08.rub.c02", "name": "Counseling the distressed juvenile and parent", "weight_points": 50, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" }, { "id": "m08.rub.c03", "name": "Disposition strategy: diversion vs. contested hearing", "weight_points": 55, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-035" }, { "id": "m08.rub.c04", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 55, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m09", "slug": "m09-dissolution-meridian", "caption": "In re the Marriage of Renata Sitko and Harlan Aldergrove", "shape": "marriage_dissolution", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "retainer", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m09.role.petitioner-counsel", "label": "Petitioner's Counsel (Renata Sitko)" }, { "role_id": "m09.role.respondent-counsel", "label": "Respondent's Counsel (Harlan Aldergrove)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m09.per.aldergrove", "name": "Harlan Aldergrove", "role": "respondent / husband", "interviewable_by": [ "m09.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m09.per.ferreira", "name": "Marisol Ferreira", "role": "fact witness (petitioner's sister)", "interviewable_by": [ "m09.role.petitioner-counsel", "m09.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m09.per.sitko", "name": "Renata Sitko", "role": "client / petitioner", "interviewable_by": [ "m09.role.petitioner-counsel" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m09-dissolution-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m09-dissolution-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m09-dissolution-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m09-dissolution-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m09.rub", "declared_total": 220, "criteria": [ { "id": "m09.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview and fact-gathering", "weight_points": 70, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m09.rub.c02", "name": "Counseling the distressed client", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" }, { "id": "m09.rub.c03", "name": "Settlement strategy and negotiation", "weight_points": 55, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-044" }, { "id": "m09.rub.c04", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" }, { "id": "m09.rub.c05", "name": "Drafting the initiating documents", "weight_points": 25, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-048" } ] } }, { "id": "m10", "slug": "m10-probate-meridian", "caption": "In re the Estate of Mabel R. Thornquist", "shape": "wills_probate", "tier": "meridian", "jurisdiction": "meridian", "fee_type": "flat", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m10.role.proponent-counsel", "label": "Proponent / Estate (Personal Representative)" }, { "role_id": "m10.role.contestant-counsel", "label": "Contestant / Objecting Heir" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m10.per.reddick", "name": "Eleanor Thornquist-Reddick", "role": "client (personal representative and principal devisee)", "interviewable_by": [ "m10.role.proponent-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m10.per.sundberg", "name": "Lorna Sundberg", "role": "fact witness (home health aide)", "interviewable_by": [ "m10.role.proponent-counsel", "m10.role.contestant-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m10.per.thornquist", "name": "Ronald Thornquist", "role": "will contestant (objecting heir)", "interviewable_by": [ "m10.role.contestant-counsel" ], "represented": true } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m10-probate-meridian/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m10-probate-meridian/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m10-probate-meridian/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m10-probate-meridian/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m10.rub", "declared_total": 210, "criteria": [ { "id": "m10.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview and fact gathering", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m10.rub.c02", "name": "Capacity and undue-influence analysis", "weight_points": 70, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-010" }, { "id": "m10.rub.c03", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" }, { "id": "m10.rub.c04", "name": "Counseling the distressed client", "weight_points": 25, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" }, { "id": "m10.rub.c05", "name": "Interview memo and litigation posture", "weight_points": 15, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-048" } ] } }, { "id": "m11", "slug": "m11-arbitration-il", "caption": "Prairie State Logistics, Inc. v. Yusuf Adeyemi (Employment Arbitration)", "shape": "employment_arbitration", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "IL", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m11.role.employee-counsel", "label": "Claimant / Employee (firm's client)" }, { "role_id": "m11.role.employer-counsel", "label": "Respondent / Employer" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m11.per.adeyemi", "name": "Yusuf Adeyemi", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m11.role.employee-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m11.per.pfeiffer", "name": "Roland Pfeiffer", "role": "adverse witness / director of operations (Respondent employer)", "interviewable_by": [ "m11.role.employee-counsel" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m11.per.ruvalcaba", "name": "Tomás Ruvalcaba", "role": "fact witness / co-worker", "interviewable_by": [ "m11.role.employee-counsel" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m11-arbitration-il/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m11-arbitration-il/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m11-arbitration-il/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m11-arbitration-il/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m11.rub", "declared_total": 202, "criteria": [ { "id": "m11.rub.c01", "name": "Statement of the Case (written advocacy)", "weight_points": 56, "skill_id": "SK-LP-09", "task_id": "TSK-032" }, { "id": "m11.rub.c02", "name": "Fact development and witness interviews", "weight_points": 46, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m11.rub.c03", "name": "Case theory and legal analysis", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-002" }, { "id": "m11.rub.c04", "name": "Arbitration hearing advocacy", "weight_points": 44, "skill_id": "SK-LP-14", "task_id": "TSK-052" }, { "id": "m11.rub.c05", "name": "Professional responsibility and counseling", "weight_points": 16, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m12", "slug": "m12-discipline-mn", "caption": "In re Petition for Disciplinary Action against Delphine A. Karsgaard, a Minnesota Attorney", "shape": "attorney_discipline", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "MN", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m12.role.disciplinary-counsel", "label": "Petitioner / Office of Lawyers Professional Responsibility" }, { "role_id": "m12.role.respondent-counsel", "label": "Respondent / Delphine A. Karsgaard (defense)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m12.per.dieterle", "name": "Marguerite Dieterle", "role": "complaining client (adverse; represented by malpractice counsel)", "interviewable_by": [ "m12.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m12.per.emberly", "name": "Jonas Emberly", "role": "fact witness (associate at respondent's firm)", "interviewable_by": [ "m12.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m12.per.karsgaard", "name": "Delphine A. Karsgaard", "role": "client (respondent attorney)", "interviewable_by": [ "m12.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m12-discipline-mn/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m12-discipline-mn/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m12-discipline-mn/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m12-discipline-mn/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m12.rub", "declared_total": 207, "criteria": [ { "id": "m12.rub.c01", "name": "Misconduct analysis across the three charges", "weight_points": 70, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" }, { "id": "m12.rub.c02", "name": "Sanction analysis and proportionality", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-007" }, { "id": "m12.rub.c03", "name": "Respondent's pre-hearing brief", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-09", "task_id": "TSK-032" }, { "id": "m12.rub.c04", "name": "Fact development and client counseling", "weight_points": 27, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m12.rub.c05", "name": "Oral argument readiness", "weight_points": 20, "skill_id": "SK-LP-08", "task_id": "TSK-026" } ] } }, { "id": "m13", "slug": "m13-tort-fl", "caption": "Sofia Reyes v. Bradley Hutchins", "shape": "auto_negligence", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "FL", "fee_type": "contingency", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m13.role.plaintiff", "label": "Plaintiff / Injured Driver" }, { "role_id": "m13.role.defense", "label": "Defendant / At-Fault Driver" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m13.per.fontaine", "name": "Gerald Fontaine", "role": "independent eyewitness", "interviewable_by": [ "m13.role.plaintiff", "m13.role.defense" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m13.per.hutchins", "name": "Bradley Hutchins", "role": "defendant driver", "interviewable_by": [ "m13.role.plaintiff", "m13.role.defense" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m13.per.reyes", "name": "Sofia Reyes", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m13.role.plaintiff" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m13-tort-fl/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m13-tort-fl/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m13-tort-fl/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m13-tort-fl/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m13.rub", "declared_total": 325, "criteria": [ { "id": "m13.rub.c01", "name": "Fact investigation and chronology", "weight_points": 70, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m13.rub.c02", "name": "Liability and comparative-fault analysis", "weight_points": 80, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-010" }, { "id": "m13.rub.c03", "name": "Damages and no-fault / PIP analysis", "weight_points": 55, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-001" }, { "id": "m13.rub.c04", "name": "Client counseling and expectation management", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-034" }, { "id": "m13.rub.c05", "name": "Settlement strategy and negotiation", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-044" }, { "id": "m13.rub.c06", "name": "Professional responsibility — no-contact rule", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m14", "slug": "m14-realestate-tx", "caption": "In re Purchase of the Cimarron Tract (Whitfield–Nakamura)", "shape": "real_estate_negotiation", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "TX", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m14.role.buyer-counsel", "label": "Buyer's Counsel (Nakamura)" }, { "role_id": "m14.role.seller-counsel", "label": "Seller's Counsel (Whitfield)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m14.per.nakamura", "name": "Kenji Nakamura", "role": "client / buyer", "interviewable_by": [ "m14.role.buyer-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m14.per.sandoval", "name": "Everett Sandoval", "role": "adjoining landowner (fact witness)", "interviewable_by": [ "m14.role.buyer-counsel", "m14.role.seller-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m14.per.whitfield", "name": "Garrett Whitfield", "role": "seller / opposing party", "interviewable_by": [ "m14.role.seller-counsel", "m14.role.buyer-counsel" ], "represented": true } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m14-realestate-tx/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m14-realestate-tx/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m14-realestate-tx/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m14-realestate-tx/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m14.rub", "declared_total": 185.5, "criteria": [ { "id": "m14.rub.c01", "name": "Fact development & title-issue diagnosis", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m14.rub.c02", "name": "Negotiation strategy & execution", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-046" }, { "id": "m14.rub.c03", "name": "Client counseling on options & risk", "weight_points": 35, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-034" }, { "id": "m14.rub.c04", "name": "Drafting deed & access terms", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-062" }, { "id": "m14.rub.c05", "name": "Professional responsibility — no-contact rule", "weight_points": 20.5, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m15", "slug": "m15-dwi-mn", "caption": "State of Minnesota v. Travis O. Wenzloff", "shape": "criminal_dwi", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "MN", "fee_type": "flat", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m15.role.defense", "label": "Defense / Defendant" }, { "role_id": "m15.role.prosecution", "label": "Prosecution / State of Minnesota" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m15.per.kallestad", "name": "Deputy Reid Kallestad", "role": "arresting deputy (State's witness)", "interviewable_by": [ "m15.role.prosecution" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m15.per.wenzloff", "name": "Travis O. Wenzloff", "role": "client (criminal defendant)", "interviewable_by": [ "m15.role.defense" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m15-dwi-mn/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m15-dwi-mn/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m15-dwi-mn/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m15-dwi-mn/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m15.rub", "declared_total": 316.5, "criteria": [ { "id": "m15.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview and fact development", "weight_points": 90, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m15.rub.c02", "name": "Issue-spotting: stop, field tests, and breath sample", "weight_points": 80, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-001" }, { "id": "m15.rub.c03", "name": "Counseling a client whose livelihood is at stake", "weight_points": 56.5, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" }, { "id": "m15.rub.c04", "name": "Plea and charge negotiation strategy", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-045" }, { "id": "m15.rub.c05", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m16", "slug": "m16-noncompete-ny", "caption": "Hudson Valley Biometrics, Inc. v. Priya Iyer", "shape": "noncompete_trade_secret", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "NY", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m16.role.plaintiff", "label": "Plaintiff / Former Employer" }, { "role_id": "m16.role.defense", "label": "Defendant / Former Employee (our client)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m16.per.iyer", "name": "Priya Iyer", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m16.role.defense" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m16.per.steinhauer", "name": "Roland Steinhauer", "role": "co-founder and chief technology officer, Hudson Valley Biometrics (adverse party representative)", "interviewable_by": [ "m16.role.plaintiff", "m16.role.defense" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m16.per.vandermeer", "name": "Naomi Vandermeer", "role": "former HVB engineer (non-party fact witness)", "interviewable_by": [ "m16.role.plaintiff", "m16.role.defense" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m16-noncompete-ny/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m16-noncompete-ny/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m16-noncompete-ny/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m16-noncompete-ny/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m16.rub", "declared_total": 189, "criteria": [ { "id": "m16.rub.c01", "name": "Preliminary-injunction standard and covenant reasonableness", "weight_points": 70, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-011" }, { "id": "m16.rub.c02", "name": "Fact development and investigation", "weight_points": 35, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m16.rub.c03", "name": "Persuasive written advocacy", "weight_points": 44, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-032" }, { "id": "m16.rub.c04", "name": "Professional-responsibility and client-counseling judgment", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m17", "slug": "m17-ucc-ny", "caption": "Empire Provisions Corp. v. Ostervold Packing Co.", "shape": "ucc_sale_of_goods", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "NY", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m17.role.buyer-counsel", "label": "Buyer / Defendant — Empire Provisions Corp." }, { "role_id": "m17.role.seller-counsel", "label": "Seller / Plaintiff — Ostervold Packing Co." } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m17.per.beltran", "name": "Marisol Beltran", "role": "client", "interviewable_by": [ "m17.role.buyer-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m17.per.ostervold", "name": "Roland Ostervold", "role": "opposing party representative", "interviewable_by": [ "m17.role.seller-counsel" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m17.per.renfrew", "name": "Tobias Renfrew", "role": "client-side fact witness", "interviewable_by": [ "m17.role.buyer-counsel" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m17-ucc-ny/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m17-ucc-ny/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m17-ucc-ny/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m17-ucc-ny/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m17.rub", "declared_total": 200, "criteria": [ { "id": "m17.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview and fact development", "weight_points": 50, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m17.rub.c02", "name": "Conformity, rejection, and acceptance analysis", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-010" }, { "id": "m17.rub.c03", "name": "Seller's price claim and remedies strategy", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-006" }, { "id": "m17.rub.c04", "name": "Litigation posture and client counseling", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-14", "task_id": "TSK-034" }, { "id": "m17.rub.c05", "name": "Professional responsibility and written communication", "weight_points": 20, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": null } ] } }, { "id": "m18", "slug": "m18-juvenile-ca", "caption": "In re J.C., a Minor (Cal. Welf. & Inst. Code § 602)", "shape": "juvenile_delinquency", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "CA", "fee_type": "hourly", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m18.role.prosecution", "label": "Prosecution / People (Alta Mesa County District Attorney)" }, { "role_id": "m18.role.juvenile-defense-counsel", "label": "Juvenile Defense Counsel (for the minor, J.C.)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m18.per.cordero-a", "name": "Ana Cordero", "role": "parent / guardian of the minor client", "interviewable_by": [ "m18.role.juvenile-defense-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m18.per.cordero-j", "name": "Jasmine Cordero (\"Jaz\")", "role": "client (minor / respondent to the wardship petition)", "interviewable_by": [ "m18.role.juvenile-defense-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m18.per.trejo", "name": "Kayla Trejo", "role": "co-participant charged separately (represented party)", "interviewable_by": [ "m18.role.juvenile-defense-counsel" ], "represented": true } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m18-juvenile-ca/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m18-juvenile-ca/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m18-juvenile-ca/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m18-juvenile-ca/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m18.rub", "declared_total": 210, "criteria": [ { "id": "m18.rub.c01", "name": "Fact investigation & the minor-client interview", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m18.rub.c02", "name": "Counseling the distressed juvenile and parent", "weight_points": 50, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" }, { "id": "m18.rub.c03", "name": "Disposition strategy: diversion vs. contested jurisdictional hearing", "weight_points": 55, "skill_id": "SK-LP-01", "task_id": "TSK-035" }, { "id": "m18.rub.c04", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 45, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" } ] } }, { "id": "m19", "slug": "m19-dissolution-ca", "caption": "In re the Marriage of Camille Beaumont and Andre Lassiter", "shape": "marriage_dissolution", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "CA", "fee_type": "retainer", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m19.role.petitioner-counsel", "label": "Petitioner's Counsel (Camille Beaumont)" }, { "role_id": "m19.role.respondent-counsel", "label": "Respondent's Counsel (Andre Lassiter)" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m19.per.beaumont", "name": "Camille Beaumont", "role": "client / petitioner", "interviewable_by": [ "m19.role.petitioner-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m19.per.lassiter", "name": "Andre Lassiter", "role": "respondent / husband", "interviewable_by": [ "m19.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": true }, { "id": "m19.per.tessier", "name": "Marguerite Tessier", "role": "fact witness (restaurant general manager and bookkeeper)", "interviewable_by": [ "m19.role.petitioner-counsel", "m19.role.respondent-counsel" ], "represented": false } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m19-dissolution-ca/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m19-dissolution-ca/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m19-dissolution-ca/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m19-dissolution-ca/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m19.rub", "declared_total": 210, "criteria": [ { "id": "m19.rub.c01", "name": "Client interview and fact-gathering", "weight_points": 65, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-022" }, { "id": "m19.rub.c02", "name": "Counseling the distressed client", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" }, { "id": "m19.rub.c03", "name": "Community-property analysis and settlement strategy", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-13", "task_id": "TSK-044" }, { "id": "m19.rub.c04", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 25, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" }, { "id": "m19.rub.c05", "name": "Drafting the initiating documents", "weight_points": 20, "skill_id": "SK-LP-17", "task_id": "TSK-048" } ] } }, { "id": "m20", "slug": "m20-probate-fl", "caption": "In re the Estate of Harold W. Prewitt", "shape": "wills_probate", "tier": "real", "jurisdiction": "FL", "fee_type": "flat", "sides": [ { "role_id": "m20.role.proponent-counsel", "label": "Proponent / Estate (Personal Representative)" }, { "role_id": "m20.role.contestant-counsel", "label": "Contestant / Objecting Heir" } ], "personas": [ { "id": "m20.per.bastien", "name": "Marisol Bastien", "role": "fact witness (home health aide)", "interviewable_by": [ "m20.role.proponent-counsel", "m20.role.contestant-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m20.per.cole", "name": "Vivian Prewitt-Cole", "role": "client (surviving spouse, personal representative, and principal devisee)", "interviewable_by": [ "m20.role.proponent-counsel" ], "represented": false }, { "id": "m20.per.prewitt", "name": "Dale Prewitt", "role": "will contestant (objecting heir)", "interviewable_by": [ "m20.role.contestant-counsel" ], "represented": true } ], "packet_url": "../matters/m20-probate-fl/index.html", "data": { "matter": "matters/m20-probate-fl/matter.json", "exercise": "matters/m20-probate-fl/exercise.json", "rubric": "matters/m20-probate-fl/rubric.json" }, "rubric_summary": { "id": "m20.rub", "declared_total": 210, "criteria": [ { "id": "m20.rub.c01", "name": "Fact gathering and client interview", "weight_points": 55, "skill_id": "SK-LP-07", "task_id": "TSK-023" }, { "id": "m20.rub.c02", "name": "Capacity and undue-influence analysis", "weight_points": 60, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-010" }, { "id": "m20.rub.c03", "name": "Homestead-devise analysis", "weight_points": 40, "skill_id": "SK-LP-02", "task_id": "TSK-011" }, { "id": "m20.rub.c04", "name": "Professional responsibility", "weight_points": 30, "skill_id": "SK-LP-16", "task_id": "TSK-060" }, { "id": "m20.rub.c05", "name": "Counseling a distressed client", "weight_points": 25, "skill_id": "SK-LP-10", "task_id": "TSK-037" } ] } } ], "taxonomy": { "skills_count": 31, "surveyed_count": 26, "extension_count": 5, "tasks_count": 108, "files": { "skills": "taxonomy/skills.json", "tasks": "taxonomy/tasks.json", "folio_crosswalk": "taxonomy/folio-crosswalk.json" } }, "firm": { "file": "firm.json", "name": "Ellingboe & Ravndal LLP", "as_of_date": "2026-06-30" }, "chat": { "ui": "../chat/index.html", "critique_ui": "../chat/critique.html", "api_contracts": "api-contracts.md" }, "pages": { "home": "../index.html", "skills_browser": "../skills/index.html", "matter_library": "../matters/index.html", "firm_dashboard": "../firm/index.html" } }